Stealing other web designer’s work
By Jim Jamesson on March 19th, 2009 | Posted in Web Design | Permalink
Not sure about other web designers out there, but I get livid when I see other web companies taking credit for work that my company produced. It’s one thing when you use someone else’s work as inspiration for your own–I’m totally cool with that, and guilty of doing the same. But to blatantly take credit for others’ work, and pass it off to clients as work they did themselves–well that’s just wrong, and boy does it piss me off. Such is the case with this clown…
Example 1: After a while, nobody will remember that you stole someone’s shit
Recently, it came to my attention that an inferior local web company has been doing exactly this–taking credit for our work. Here’s two screenshots showing my original work, and the work they claim as their own:My problem with this: Adding an oak leaf with improper shadow does not make this your work. While this website is no longer representative of my company’s quality or capabilities, the fact remains that this web company did not originally do this work, and this guy is taking credit for it.
Why this sucks for the client: Sucks for the client because ever since the new web company took over the project, a simple link in the footer has pointed to a broken link the entire time. Goes to show you the complete lack of quality control and attention to detail on work this company produces. Also, the leaf’s shadow that was added is completely inconsistent with any of the other shadows across the website. This web designer does not understand the importance of continuity on a website, and the client suffers as a result. (What does the designer care, he made his $ from client. Shows you he simply doesn’t give a shit about how his clients’ websites are presented in the long run.)
Example 2: the pitfalls of stealing someone’s shit is that your work looks like shit next to the original
The second example perhaps best shows the difference in quality between our two companies. The original design, and the butchered rip off:My problem with this: I’m not sure what connotations the brick wall background really have. I have never, in the history of my dealings with many rock climbers and spelunkers addicted to rappelling, seen anyone climb a brick wall. Oh, and they ganked my original concept about as much as possible.
Why this sucks for the client: The original design was built in Code Igniter, a very solid and stable PHP web framework. The new web company, unable to fathom the use of Code Igniter or ay other database-dependent framework, somehow convinced the client to pay for a complete website overhaul, rather than simply paying a legitimate professional a couple hours worth of time to make the changes. Is it any wonder why people are afraid to pay good money for web design?
Example 3, when you can’t come up with your own idea, just steal someone else’s
The third example is a little tougher to see. A few days ago I was talking with a buddy of mine about his website, when he told me of a new competitor of his that had completely cloned and ripped not only his website, but his basic business model as well. After showing me the asshole’s website, it was interesting that I was brought right back to the very same design company which loves hijacking my work.Out of respect for my client and friend, I’m not going to post the screenshots of this.
These kind of tactics really chap my web designing ass. Of the 13 examples offered on their portfolio, by my math, 23% of these examples you can plainly see ripping me off. We feel that several other examples can be traced back to our work as well. Personally, anything more than a 4 or 5% rip-off ratio adjusts my Facebook status from Flattered to Furious. I mean best I can figure, a potential client visits my site, and this turkey’s site. Sees a similar quality of work (because he stole my good shit), but goes with the crappy guy because he is 1/4 the price. Hmm, now that doesn’t seem like fair business practice to me.
I think now is maybe a good time to write this chump an open letter. Hopefully he reads it the next time he’s scouring my websites for ideas to hijack. Hopefully he realizes that he just made a massive error in judgement, and corrects the issues. Of course, I seriously doubt it.
Open letter to the guy who stole my shit
Dear [guy that steals our shit],I gotta give you some credit man, you’ve got some real balls. Not only did you make the decision to steal our shit, but you then had the audacity to continuously come to us for business advice. You’ve got a real pair of swingers, dude. The more I think about it, the more pissed I become. But for some reason, I take some comfort knowing that our stuff is leagues better than yours, and the websites we produce not only look better, but perform better for our clients as well.
I have been busting my ass on the web now for over 15 years, and I’ve seen loads of guys like yourself come and go in my industry. If history is any guide, you’ll also go away in time. Companies like yours will never thrive because you lack the ability to establish your own unique identity. Clients will eventually fizzle and fade away, and your true lack of web experience and business ethic will shine through like wizz through a cheap diaper.
Oh, and maybe you should even consider thanking me while you’re drafting your pathetic apology/excuse. See, I’m pretty easy-going most of the time, and today you caught me in a peachy mood and lucked out in a big way because Sirius 3 is jamming some Lionel Ritchie, which calms me down and brings out my inner peace. (Technically, it was the Commodores.) Make no mistake though–the thought of contacting each and every one of your clients and informing them of your tactics has undoubtedly crossed my mind. The notion of ripping off your hard work and creating a website to mock you has certainly been entertained.
Instead, maybe I should just make efforts to effectively advertise to your clients that better options do indeed exist. The Asheville and WNC region is home to many quality web professionals, many of whom Groovy Web Design considers their friends, not just competing business acquaintances. See these guys and gals are extremely hard working, trustworthy, and always practice morally-sound business ethics. None of them would ever stick their proverbial dick in our proverbial ass like you have. I guess you’ll just be out of the cool people loop forever.
It’s sad because with a little more tact and an honest approach, you could have actually propelled yourself into a contender of the web world. (Well, probably not.) But no. Ultimately you chose web design as a means to make money, and not as a means to produce quality web content for your clients. And thats exactly the line of thinking which will lead to your demise. Actually, it will probably be the pending litigation from another company (with deep pockets) that you stole from as well, who we just learned is not happy with you as well.
In closing, I just wanna make one thing clear: Stop stealing my shit. Like, right now. My workload and schedule are pretty much booked, but do I have the ability and determination to find free time to build a website that not only mocks and directly competes with you in your market, but also be built far superior to yours, and would out-think you and out-SEO you on every single keyword and tactic you currently use. Because, dude lets face it… if we boil down and compare our stuff, my work is always going to kick your work’s ass. Game on?
Regards, Jim
8 Comments
Tags: plagiarizing web design, Shitty web design company




Very, very well said.
It’s such a shame, especially for the thief’s clients, that they receive something that’s not unique. They might as well have just gone to template monster and purchased something for about seventy five bucks. At least a local competitor wouldn’t have the same, identical, ripped-off design.
And on the ethics, it’s just morally wrong. Like with communication: You should always present your words, yourself, your work, and everything else clearly and accurately. Not doing so introduces inconsistencies, most of which you will have a hard time keeping up with. When you don’t present clearly, everyone suffers.
Comment by Steve on March 24, 2009
I’ve seen countless examples of this as well. However, since I’m pretty much strictly a “developer” and don’t deal with design hardly at all, I don’t have too much to worry about.
I have had people steal my code ideas though. What sucks really bad is when you’re a small piss-ant compared to the people who steal your shit. So you could have some outstanding content that people would love, but since you’re so small… No one really notices.
However, the big dude rips your shit and posts it as his own, and VOILA! It’s an instant hit! Fuckers.
Keep up the good work, fuck ‘em all!
Comment by Josh on March 26, 2009
What a fucktard. We’re seeing this in increasing amounts as a whole army of print designers get booted out of the paper world and come to the web. I suppose many are terrified of losing money and work, so theft is not a great deterrent. I do use other designs as a starting point often, however I make so many changes by the end, you can’t recognize the original. The part about ripping out Code Ignitor is just sad. To many inexperienced “designers”, it’s all about the look of the site. To them, it’s just a motorized brochure. If you’re really on top of the game, you’ll do a great continuous design that is built on top of a dynamic framework. It should allow the client to do easy edits. Not only that, but other coders/designers can come after and know what the hell is going on by taking one look at the folder structure. The real bitch is that many clients think that all we web people do is push buttons anyway. In that respect, we certainly must rip off each others shit in the first place. Along comes some kid in the red house on the corner claiming $600 for a whole site. It’s hook line and sinker because it “looks great”. Thank god for Lionel Ritchie, because I’d hate to see Jim huck that fucking strong tag at the perpetrator.
Comment by Lance Wig on March 27, 2009
Yeah, That’s not cool at all! I don’t know why people do it either?? Stealing other peoples work is wrong!
I do know that designers can copyright their photos and place script on their web pages that prohibit users from copying and saving images to their desktop. But, with code….maybe there will be something in the future that prevents people from stealing code? That would be a good thing!
Comment by Rob Stathem on April 24, 2009
Hey there,
buy copying your stuff they just admit that they aren’t and will never be a real webdesigner. Starting a “Webdesigning & developing company” and copying someone’s work is pretty poor. Inspiration is a good thing, looking at someones art on the net and getting ideas is cool ( that’s what a real designer should have ), but copying is really lame. A webdesigner needs to be creative & smart. By copying stuff, the person admits that he is none of that and just a wannabe designer. It’s like the chinese copies Cars like BMW, Mercedes, & so on. BMW & Mercedes just laugh about it, because, everybody knows it was their idea, to build a car which looks like that.
So here’s the problem, you are pissed of ( which is completely normal, who wouldnt be? ) becuase you have your personal type of art, something that makes your design unique compared to others. But only 5% or even less of the people know that and recognizes that. Not like the BMW, Merc. case. Everybody knows them somehow.That’s why they can laugh about it and you cant…
This is one of the worst and also funniest thing’s ive ever heard, copying others stuff and present it as their own stuff. the best thing this person should probably do is finding another job because obviously that guys is too dumb and too uncreative, to create an own style, an own work.
Comment by Toby on July 9, 2009
I VERY! much agree with you. Taking credit for someone else work and getting inspired are two very different things and it sickens and saddens me to think people really do that and think they will get away with it….
Comment by Trae on February 19, 2010
well said but you cant do anything ! i think prevention is better than cure
Comment by amrishwa on March 4, 2010
may be two people thinks same [red]i am not the one who stealed your design[/red]
Comment by amrishwa on March 4, 2010